This 17k-mile 2009 Mini Cooper S sold for $16,500 on Bring a Trailer, and that’s strong money given the fair value estimate of $10,412 — it’s clearly overpriced.

This Mini Cooper S is a gem for a few reasons. First off, it’s got just 17,000 miles on the clock, which is practically unheard of for a car of this age. The turbocharged 1.6-liter inline-four engine paired with a six-speed manual transaxle makes it a fun drive. Manual transmissions are increasingly rare in this segment, and that alone boosts its appeal. Plus, this car comes loaded with options, including Sport, Premium, Cold Weather, and Convenience Packages. The 17” Crown Spoke wheels and xenon headlights add to the aesthetic, while the panoramic sunroof and leatherette interior elevate the comfort level.

Bidding reached 43 participants, indicating solid interest, but the final sale price reflects a market that’s willing to pay a premium for low mileage, well-optioned cars. That said, selling for $16,500 puts it 59% above the fair value estimate. Buyers usually expect to snag a low-mileage Mini at a more reasonable price, so this feels like a bit of an outlier.

One community member, Kazillac, placed the final bid of $16,500, signaling their confidence in the car’s condition and specs. Another bidder, ObiWon, was close behind at $16,250, showing that there was genuine competition for this Mini. Still, the comments reflect a mix of admiration for the car and skepticism about the price.

For anyone hunting a similar car, watch for service history and any modifications. While this Mini has a clean Carfax, understanding how the vehicle was treated in its life can make a significant difference in long-term reliability and enjoyment. Low mileage is great, but if it hasn’t been driven much, it’s crucial to confirm that it was well-maintained. Overall, this sale indicates that while low-mileage models command high prices, the market can be tricky — know your numbers and be ready to walk away if the bidding gets too heated.

See all Mini R56 Cooper, Cooper S, and John Cooper Works listings on [Friday's Watchlist](https://fridayswatchlist.com/search?make=Mini&model=R56%20Cooper,%20Cooper%20S,%20and%20John%20Cooper%20Works).