$133,996 for a 28k-mile 2005 Porsche 911 Turbo S Cabriolet with a six-speed manual is strong money — no question about it.

This Turbo S Cabriolet is a prime example of early-2000s Porsche engineering, combining the thrill of a twin-turbocharged 3.6-liter flat-six engine with the engagement of a manual transmission. The low mileage of just 28,000 miles means it still has plenty of life left. Plus, the GT Silver Metallic finish paired with a Black Full leather interior gives it a refined look that appeals to both drivers and collectors. The allure of a six-speed manual in a turbocharged Porsche adds a layer of driving excitement that many enthusiasts crave, making this spec highly desirable.

However, when you look at the sale price of $133,996 against the fair value estimate of $78,900, it's hard to argue that this was anything but a premium over what most would consider market-correct. The bidding frenzy saw 54 participants, indicating high interest, but the final price still landed 70% above fair value, suggesting that buyers were either heavily invested in the car's rarity or just caught up in the auction excitement. While passion often drives auction results, the numbers tell a different story.

The community reaction was mixed, with one user, @Chopper849, throwing shade at the newer models and their oil-sump designs, saying, "a new one” ??? Another user expressed regret at missing out on this local gem, saying, “I really wanted this one, particularly because it was local, but couldn’t get to the finish line.” It’s clear that while some were thrilled for the new owner, others felt the price was a bit steep for a model that’s still a few generations behind the current offerings.

For anyone on the hunt for a similar car, it’s crucial to vet the auction history and market trends thoroughly. Look for comparable sales that reflect current demand and condition. Keep an eye on mileage, as lower numbers typically fetch higher bids, but don’t overlook condition and spec. A well-maintained model with desirable options can command a premium, but always measure that against recent sales data to avoid overbidding.

See all Porsche 996 911 Turbo listings on [Friday's Watchlist](https://fridayswatchlist.com/search?make=Porsche&model=996%20911%20Turbo).